I know this is a bit too late to review something that came & went in October, but since this the my last Ipsy Glam Bag I thought I will share the stuff & tell why I stopped my subscription to Ipsy.
I really liked this month's bag - a blue-green shade with shiny puffer design. I will definitely be using this one. This month bag came with 5 products including this face wipes from Skyn.
The cloths themselves look like normal cleansing wipes but actually feels soapier and has a kinda "lathered in soap" feeling. Considering that these facial wipes are to be used without water, I don't understand why they have made it so soapy. It stings the eyes like crazy too! Don't use this for your mascara unless you're planning to wash your face with water. I made the mistake of using this without washing and it stung like crazy.
I couldn't really see much of an effect either, other than cleaning out the makeup nicely. Considering the hefty price tag of this product,[$16.50 at Murale] I think I will stick to my baby wipes, thank you very much!
The other products I received were:
- City Colors Be Matte Lipsticks in shade Cappuccino
- Jesse's girl Mineralized Eyeshadow in Plum Frost
- Remy Hair Envy Fake Eyelashes
- Fig & Rouge Hand Cream
This is a most useful product for me now - cos of the fact that Jack Frost is on the way & you can never have enough hand creams. This nifty sleek tube is handy for travel. The bohemian packaging is eye catching but green, yellow , pink and blue all together? A bit too gakk for me. Still a hand cream is a hand cream! I am not going to try hard to repurchase this as honestly - I can really think of any reason why I would trouble my head over a hand cream.
This is useful and I dont have to worry about expiry dates [hopefully, does fake eyelashes go bad?ever?] so may be I will try this out sometime soon. I am not a huge fan of fake eyelashes as I have this habit of washing my eyes with cold water every 3-4 hours - it helps relax my eyes but doesnt help with any eye makeup.
This eyeshadow from Jesse's Girl Mineralized Baked Powder range has been around a while - I saw a post from Musingsofamuse from 2011. I am all for shades of plum as it goes well with my skin tone. My only problem with this eyeshadow is that this has to be applied wet or over a primer. There are baked eyeshadows which go well dry and excellent when wet, but this one just goes dusty when dry. To get the color on the pan, its got to be wet!
In the pic above, it is showing up more copper - this is not a true plum shade. It is a coppery plum-ish shade.
Matte lipsticks are always great for a classic look and I guess once you cross 30, you get into a mood for classic matte lips, especially on a daily basis. Thats the only explanation I can think of on why a creamy-lipstick lover like me now favors the matte finish.
This lipstick in shade Cappuccino is a good choice for all those who love the recent Kendall/Kylie Jenner lips. Cappuccino is a reddish brown slightly creamy matte lipstick, with some hints of peach in it.
I like this color and will be definitely getting a lot of use out of it as its a good office-wear shade.
 |
| From Top to bottom - City Colors Be Matte Lipstick in Cappuccino, Jesse's girl eyeshadow applied dry and slightly wet. |
Overall: This is pretty decent bag, nothing "WOWOWOW" but nothing I cannot use. All the products have some use or other; my favorite out of the bunch is definitely the lipstick.
Now, to the story of why this is the last Ipsy Glam bag for me.....
I have this habit of stashing all my subscription box products in one kit as opposed to mixing it up with my regular purchases. This October, I was arranging my stash when I noticed how little do I use all the products I get from these subscription boxes. That really made me think - is it worth getting a hoard of new stuff which I don't use as much as I wish?
I think the reason is because - I don't select these products, so they are not my choice- so I don't have the same comfort level with these ones as I've with items I like & buy for a reason. For example, take this eyeshadow in this month's bag. I don't think I will ever buy it, cos I prefer matte shades that have much more pigmentation - which I don't usually get from drugstore shadows. Same with many other products I receive in the subscription boxes - not my choice, not something I will buy or use, so I drift off to stuff I like & am comfortable with.
For $10 a month + $5 in shipping, Ipsy is not a wallet-breaker and is a fun way to try out new stuff every month. However, when I think of the total amount I have spent so far [from December 2013 to October 2014],its a goodish amount of $165 CAD! But do the set of products which I like & use justify the amount I've spent? So I decided to take an inventory of all the stuff I've got so far from Ipsy.
- POP Beauty Bright Up Your Life Eye Shadow Trio - Not used, didnt like
- Be a Bombshell The One Stick - Okay, but too shimmery and greasy
- Nicka K New York Nail Color - Like the shade
- Ardell Natural Lash - Not used
- J.Cat Beauty Big Lip Pencil - Okay, nothing great
- Elizabeth Mott Smooth Shadow - Liked it, easy to use
- Nourish Organic Lightweight Moisturizing Face Lotion - Okay, nothing great
- Faith Aromatherapy Tahitian Monoi Anti-Aging Sugar Scrub - Not used, too small size
- MicaBeauty Tinted Lip Balm - Used, didnt like
- Sexy Hair Healthy Sexy Hair Soy Tri-Wheat Leave In Conditioner - Okay, nothing great
- POP Beauty Plump Pout Mini - Okay, nothing great
- Zoya Nail Polish - Liked the product, but not the shade
- City Color Be Matte Blush - Okay, didnt like the shade
- Tini Beauty Eyetini Cordial Cream Shadow + Base In One - Okay, nothing great
- Pacifica Hawaiian Ruby Guava Body Butter - swapped
- bareMinerals Marvelous Moxie™ Lipstick in Get Ready - Like the lipstick but not the shade
- NYX Love in Rio Eye Shadow - Okay, used once but not a fan
- Chella Indigo Blue Eyeliner - Okay, used once but not a fan
- Pixi Beauty Flawless Beauty Primer- Didnt like
- Urban Decay 24/7 Velvet Glide-On Eye Pencil Travel Size - Liked
- Coastal Scents Medium Shadow Brush - Okay, used once but not a fan
- dr. brandt® microdermabrasion - Okay, used once
- Elizabeth Mott pop! goes the shadow - Didnt get
- Starlooks Luscious Longwear Lip Pencil- Not used
- Hang Ten Classic Sport SPF50 - Not used
- Pacifica Mineral Eyeshadow Duo - Didnt like
- Avène Thermal Spring Water - Liked
- Nailtini Straight Up Color Nail Lacquer (Frappe, Champagne, Bloody Mary, Caviar Cocktail) - Liked
- Pur~lisse pur~moist hydra balance moisturizer- Okay, used once but not a fan
- Be A Bombshell Lash Out Mascara - Didnt like
- DERMAdoctor DD Cream Dermatologically Defining BB Cream with Broad Spectrum SPF 30- okay nothing great
- Marc Anthony Dream Waves Beach Spray - Okay, used once but not a fan
- Nicka K New York Shimmer Eyeliner - Okay, used once but not a fan
- NYX Butter Gloss Tiramisu - Like the product but not the shade
- bareMinerals READY® Eyeshadow 2.0 - Okay, nothing great
- Elizabeth Mott Tints & Sass - Okay, used once but not a fan
- Hang Ten dark Tanning Oil SPF 08 - Useless
- Marrakesh Hair Care Marrakesh Endz- Useless
- wHet Nail Polish in Facetious- Didnt like the shade
- nicka K Absolute Lip Balm - Didnt like the product
- Dr. Brandt Pores No More Pore Refiner- Okay, nothing great
- Urban Decay Perversion Mascara - Okay, nothing great
- Coastal Scents Forever Blush Sample Duo - Too small to use, cant dip a brush in
- Lord & Berry Silk Kajal Kohl Eye Pencil- Okay, nothing great
- Crown Brush Infinity Shadow/Crease Duet Brush - Okay notthing great
- Pacifica Natural Water-Proof Eye Pencil - Liked
- Briogeo Don’t Despair, Repair!™ Deep Conditioning Mask - Okay, nothing great
- CAILYN Art Touch Tinted Lip Gloss - Okay. but didnt like the shade very much
- Nourish Organic Moisturizing Cream Face Cleanser - Okay, nothing great
Out of the 49 products I received [excluding this month's bag], there are only 8 products that I like and will get some good use out of. There are other products like Ardell lashes which I have not used but may get a use out of some day and products like NYX Butter Gloss where I like the product itself but not the shade. Out of the 5 products I received in this month's bag, the ones I'd probably get some real use of of are the Lipstick and the hand cream.That makes a total of 8 products out of a total of 54. Does this at least cover the cost I paid? Lets check.
- Nicka K nail polish - $5 approx
- UD eyeliner - $24 for full size[0.04 oz] ; travel size Ipsy [0.03 oz] is $18
- Avene Thermal Spring Water - $16.29 for 5.0721 oz; for Ipsy size of 1.76 oz, $5.65
- Nailtini Nail Lacquer: Ipsy full size is $13 USD = $15 CAD approx
- Pacifica eye pencil: Full size 0.1 oz is $11.50, Ipsy size 0.026 oz is $2.99 CAD
- Elizabeth mott eye pencil- $14.99 USD for 0.05 oz; Ipsy size is 0.$7.5 for 025 oz i.e. $9 CAD approx
- City colors be matte lipstick - Ipsy Full size is $5 USD = approx $7 CAD
- Fig & Rouge hand cream - Ipsy size 20ml is $6.37 USD = $7.5 CAD approx
Amount in Opportunity cost [i.e. the remaining amount which I could have used to buy stuff I like & use] = $95 CAD
Thats a pretty high amount, right?
I think Ipsy is very good & value for money and excellent if you want to try different brands. The problem is that different or new doesn't equate to liking the stuff.
What would make me try Ipsy again
I feel that their customer profiling and customization is not that great yet; for e.g . I am an Indian with all the tan in the world I need, but I got a tanning oil!
So, I would try Ipsy again if I hear that their customization is better or if they come up with an option for me to select at least 3 or 4 items in the bag. If someone from Ipsy is reading this mail - how about allowing your customers to select at least 3 items in a bag that will come out in 1-2 months? That will give Ipsy enough time to place orders [I think?] and make us customers happy - right?
Overall: Its been an interesting journey with Ipsy; I have got a lot of products and if I was able to enjoy all of it, it would have been perfect! But nothing is perfect in this world, so Adieu for now Ipsy...
